Could India continue to drive returns for Emerging Markets?India shined as one of the best performing markets globally in 2023 despite high global inflation, rising interest rates, and unstable geopolitics. The Sensex and Nifty, two widely followed benchmarks for the Indian markets, grew 19.57% and 21.11% respectively in US Dollar (USD) terms1.
India’s economy displayed strong local retail demand, moderate inflation, stable interest rates and healthy foreign exchange reserves. India also enjoyed relatively healthy relations with most major economies of the world and cautiously navigated the geopolitical conflicts.
As we look ahead in 2024, we remain confident that India, driven by a host of macroeconomic factors, is a long-term story and one that could last for years if not decades to come. National elections are due to be held around May 2024. Current Prime Minister Narendra Modi is seeking a historic third term and it is highly likely that the ruling party, Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), will once again win with a full majority.
India benefits from Modi’s pro-business and pro-growth policies and a stable political environment further boosts prospects to realise rapid growth. We analysed the performance of BSE Sensex, one of the widely followed benchmarks of the Indian stock market, pre and post elections.
On average, the Indian markets displayed positive performance, delivering over 31% returns over the year leading up to elections, combined with the year after election results. This is despite the global financial crisis of 2008, and the COVID-19 drawdown negatively impacting the performance leading to 2009 elections, and after the 2019 elections respectively. We expect this trend to continue with the likely return of the incumbent government.
Of course, should Modi lose, some of the recent gains might reverse. However, that seems highly unlikely, given the state of opposition, as multiple political parties, including some with completely unaligned agendas have joined hands to prevent a third Modi term. This was evident over the five recent elections in which the BJP won by huge majority in three of the largest states with a high proportion of the Lok Sabha (national election) constituencies.
Other important factors that investors might want to keep an eye on during the year:
1. Rate cuts – The Federal Reserve’s pace and timing on rate cuts will impact global markets and India is no different. The quicker and higher the cuts, the more the capital expected to be diverted towards equities, and with a strong momentum from the previous year, India might be one of the top picks in the Emerging Markets.
2. Crude oil prices – The Indian economy heavily depends on the import of crude oil. The higher the crude oil prices, the more the stress on India’s foreign current accounts. Drops in crude oil could help India’s economy grow faster and allow more room for spending on growth and infrastructure. India is simultaneously also working to reduce dependency on crude oil by diversifying into ethanol. Over the last few years, ethanol production has increased manifold and there is rising pressure to increase the usage of ethanol-blended fuel to power vehicles. This could potentially save the country much needed cash and help direct it to fuel economic growth and reduce fiscal deficits.
3. China decoupling – India has emerged as one of the most credible contenders to help diversify manufacturing out of China. For example, Apple established a considerable footprint and plans to scale up operations multi-fold; significant investments and subsidies were introduced to attract semiconductor companies from Taiwan; and there are also suggestions that Tesla is looking to enter India with a USD 2 billion investment into a manufacturing facility based in the state of Gujrat.
One of the most iconic policies of the current government over the last decade has been ‘Make in India’. The government will be pushing hard to attract more companies to set up manufacturing plants in India and leverage the success of ‘Make in India’ among voters.
4. Geopolitical instability – India has been relatively less impacted by geopolitical conflicts around the globe. India maintained its neutral stance and successfully managed to stand firm despite pressure from the west by importing discounted oil from Russia to ensure its energy security, while at the same time pitched itself as a closer ally to the US to counter the growing China threat.
5. Retail flows – In the recent years, India witnessed increasing participation of retail investors in the stock market. There are 80 million unique investors in the Indian stock markets that invest through the NSE.2 Moreover, the size of mutual fund AUM is around 24% currently compared to 11% a decade ago. The strong retail presence helps add stability to the Indian markets in events of global instability and Foreign Institutional Investor (FII) outflows.
Conclusion
We strongly believe that India is a multi-decade story, and we are in very early stages of it. India has made tremendous progress in privatising corruption and debt-ridden state-owned companies, with disinvestments fetching USD 50 billion for the government over the last 10 years, out of which close to USD 40 billion was realised from sales of minority stakes, while close to USD 10 billion was realised from strategic transactions in 10 CPSEs – with the most notable being Air India3. This has helped in making companies more accountable to investors and more accessible via the stock market.
Sources
1 Source: WisdomTree, Bloomberg.
2 Source: According to recent comments from CEO of National Stock Exchange (NSE)
3 See: Disinvestment fetches over Rs 4.20 lakh cr in 10 years but target to be missed again in FY24, December 2023
This material is prepared by WisdomTree and its affiliates and is not intended to be relied upon as a forecast, research or investment advice, and is not a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities or to adopt any investment strategy. The opinions expressed are as of the date of production and may change as subsequent conditions vary. The information and opinions contained in this material are derived from proprietary and non-proprietary sources. As such, no warranty of accuracy or reliability is given and no responsibility arising in any other way for errors and omissions (including responsibility to any person by reason of negligence) is accepted by WisdomTree, nor any affiliate, nor any of their officers, employees or agents. Reliance upon information in this material is at the sole discretion of the reader. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.
Coupling
How today put me on the sidelinesThose of us in the crypto community investment world face unique , often unpredictable challenges .
Divergent press. Entities such as C.C.N. and Nulltx, and others who when the market is up start spamming tradeview with negative bias, and when it's down make public the often absurdly laughable predictions of riches. The people who own and control the press represent big money , and big money comes with incessant greed. They will publish stories simply to try to buy in cheaper, at your expense. If only divergent press were bullish like the klinger.
2. Crypto as an asset, yet with a forex aspect. Today I was doing well. Made a few here and there off some unexpected price trends, like BCH- who ever thought THAT would happen?? But primarily I was into XRP today. We all know that various exchanges couple currencies. It is the oft used complaint about how Bitcoin pulls the market , but today it did so in an insidious fashion.
Nothing moves like crypto , and if you re here , you likely have some belief in the future of money being digital. Today defied almost every metric as I watched in horror as the price of XRP plummeted , with only one metric showing it would do so. EASE of movement, exponential. It bottomed out as the price of XRP rose against Bitcoin , which also rose. At some point the Forex factor came into play. In reverse though; XRP's gain against BTC , combined with positive BTC activity brought it tumbling down. When a gain on another currency causes a drop vs. fiat things get confusing.
3. Why the forex factor?? I use a variety of exchanges on tradeview to measure price , as well as the metrics offered by the exchange I happen to be on that day. I seem destined to learn the hard way. The prices began to fall in a way that made no sense. The order books were getting washed , with the prices of XRP dropping so quickly it was hard to sell in time. A later look showed what should have been a positive for XRP , a gain in value against BTC. Herein is another problem with coupling. An opportunity for arbitrage set in at one point, and with the price of BTC on the rise , people were dumping their XRP in the one place I didn't look - XRP-BTC.
4. We aren't just holding commodities , there is a forex element in play here , and Forex is the one thing I can think of as more volatile than crypto. Even now, XRP is down from what looked like a promising rally. You can have 7 , 8 different metrics on your screen , measures of volatility , AXM/DMS , Elder Ray , Fractal Chaos - what ever floats your boat , but the only one that gave warning as to what was about to happen was EASE of movement. Set to exponential , it really works, and it nosedived just prior to the price. When what seemed to be a recovery from rock bottom turned into what seemed like a nightmare with no end in sight - long , red bars on tradeview stopping for nothing and nobody , panic ensued.
5. I am not a financial advisor , and have learned my lessons the hard way. One does NOT HODL. Not if you want to retain risk capital. Using market order is a ripoff , just as instant is , yet the velocity of the downturn made executing the sale from tradeview nearly impossible.
6. This market has NOT yet seen it's bottom , contrary to what the press would like you to believe. Certain currencies may have , others may become worthless. On a day like today , crypto feels like playing with dice.
7. Coinbase has now coupled and added several currencies. Coinbase has a dubious history. In times past a coinbase listing was a "pump," later it became more of a dump, but one of the worlds most popular platforms has coupled currencies that they hadn't before. Claiming to own so much BTC and LTC , one can see where that influence plays a part.
8 I apologize for urging people not to panic. I am not urging you to go ahead and do so , and I am no financial advisor , but I firmly believe that crypto is now the equivalent of an online casino.
With the additional couplings come a whole new set of parameters , and it is not just coinbase that I speak of. You are engaging in a form of forex now with only one advantage, you wont lose more than you put in. Unless of course you margin trade - and good luck with that.
9. Cryptocurrency is becoming increasingly centralized. That is just plain obvious , and if you dont think so , read the coinbase headline. Look at the consolidation of mining power and pools, with so many lost to the bear market of 2018 , we face that threat as well as the Banks goal of Fractional Reserve Centralized Cryptocurrency. They will even tell you that we NEED it. Most terrible things are sold to us in the service of convenience , yet turn out to be anything but. The IMF , World bank etc. are all salivating at the eventual goal of globalization , and if you are reading this , your using the technology that threatens to bring us down. The internet of places and things is quickly becoming the internet of money.
10. Crypto faces state level sanctions. Do you believe that Iran and other countries levied with financial sanctions will be permitted to simply skirt by them using crypto?? Don't drink that batch of Kool-Aid.
I think the only way to win at this point is shorting , and carefully hedging your bets , because thats what they are - bets. If you want to see a 10 or 20 percent return on the lucky crypto of the day , you had best keep a close watch on that screen , and a stop loss that covers your fee's.
Caveat emptor.